Politics

Court rules House’s 2022 spending bill passage unconstitutional

A divided appeals court ruled that proxy participation could not establish a House quorum for a 2022 spending bill. Its injunction concerns enforcement of pregnancy accommodation protections against Texas.

Editorial illustration of the U.S. Capitol and a congressional desk representing the House proxy voting ruling.
An editorial illustration of the U.S. Capitol and a congressional voting desk.HOURLY / AI-ASSISTED EDITORIAL ILLUSTRATION

House proxy voting could not establish the quorum needed to pass a major 2022 spending bill, the Fifth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled on November 20 in a closely divided decision.

The 9-8 ruling upheld an injunction preventing federal enforcement of the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act against Texas. The remedy does not block the entire spending package nationwide.

What the House proxy voting ruling decided

The majority, led by Judge Cory Wilson, concluded that lawmakers must be physically present to count toward a constitutional quorum. It rejected counting absent members through proxies for that purpose.

Judge James Graves dissented, disputing the physical-presence requirement and questioning the narrow remedy attached to a finding about the bill’s overall passage.

How the December 2022 vote worked

The House clerk’s official roll call records the vote on December 23, 2022. The measure received 225 votes in favor and 201 against, with one member voting present and four not voting.

The party breakdown shows 216 Democrats and nine Republicans supporting the measure. One Democrat and 200 Republicans opposed it. Those totals describe the recorded positions on the bill; they do not, by themselves, show which lawmakers were physically inside the chamber.

The spending measure became the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023. The appeals court’s earlier account of the case explains that the House used pandemic-era procedures allowing members to participate without being physically present.

Why a quorum differs from a winning vote

Article I, Section 5 of the Constitution establishes that a majority of each chamber constitutes a quorum for conducting business. It separately allows each chamber to determine its procedural rules.

The distinction is between having enough members to conduct business and having enough votes to approve a particular measure. A recorded majority supporting legislation does not settle a separate dispute about whether the chamber met its constitutional quorum requirement.

The constitutional text also permits a smaller number of members to adjourn from day to day and authorizes measures to compel absent members to attend. The dispute concerns how those provisions apply when members participate through someone else.

The case previously produced the opposite result

A three-judge Fifth Circuit panel reached a different conclusion about House proxy voting in August 2025. That panel held that the Quorum Clause did not require physical presence and reversed the district court’s judgment.

The panel opinion described House Resolution 965, adopted on May 15, 2020, as the framework for remote participation during the coronavirus emergency. Members could designate another lawmaker to cast a vote or record their presence, using a signed letter identifying the proxy.

That earlier account also explained the federal government’s enrolled-bill argument: an officially authenticated bill should prevent the court from reviewing the challenge. The panel allowed judicial review but disagreed with Texas on the quorum question. Friday’s decision reached the opposite conclusion on physical presence.

What the pregnancy accommodation law covers

The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission’s explanation says the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act generally requires covered employers to reasonably accommodate known limitations related to pregnancy, childbirth or related medical conditions, unless doing so creates an undue hardship.

The law took effect on June 27, 2023. It generally covers private employers and state or local government employers with at least 15 employees, along with federal agencies, Congress and certain other employment organizations.

The EEOC distinguishes accommodation requirements from other protections against pregnancy discrimination. It also says the law does not replace federal, state or local rules that provide stronger worker protections.

Examples listed by the agency include more flexible breaks, adjustments to work schedules, a stool for tasks normally performed standing, and leave for medical appointments. These are possible accommodations, rather than a promise that every request must be granted. The agency describes undue hardship as significant difficulty or expense.

The practical scope of the House proxy voting decision therefore matters: this injunction concerns enforcement against Texas, rather than a nationwide order eliminating every provision of the spending law.

Sources

Read smarter

Get The Hourly Brief in your inbox.

Essential U.S. politics, business, technology and health news—selected and explained by Hourly Times.

Join the newsletter