Elections

John McEntee reportedly beats Vance and Rubio in two campus straw polls

John McEntee reportedly finished first in two campus Republican straw polls. The results do not establish national support, and their sample sizes and collection methods remain unverified.

John McEntee against a blurred university-style background; AI-assisted editorial illustration for coverage of reported campus straw polls.
An editorial illustration of John McEntee accompanying reporting about two campus Republican straw polls. The background is symbolic.HOURLY / AI-ASSISTED EDITORIAL ILLUSTRATION

John McEntee reportedly finished ahead of JD Vance and Marco Rubio in two campus Republican straw polls, drawing attention to the former Trump aide as discussion of the 2028 presidential race develops. The figures concern groups at the University of Tennessee and Penn State, not Republican voters nationwide.

Newsweek reported the results November 13. Its original page could not be directly reviewed for this article; reproductions of the report and third-party views of the groups’ announcements were available. The underlying voting records were not independently verified.

The reported Tennessee figures put McEntee at 31.3%, Rubio at 29.7%, Ron DeSantis at 23.4% and Vance at 15.6%. At Penn State, the reported shares were 42% for McEntee, 23% for Rubio, 15% for DeSantis, 11% for Thomas Massie and 8% for Vance.

The five Penn State percentages reproduced in the report add to 99%. Without the original tabulation, the remaining percentage point cannot be assigned to undecided voters, another candidate or any particular cause.

What the John McEntee straw-poll results establish

The announcements identify a reported preference among participants in two campus exercises. They do not establish how Republican primary voters across either state, or across the country, would vote.

Important details could not be confirmed: how many people participated, who was eligible, how participants were recruited, whether repeat responses were prevented and exactly how the presidential preference question was presented.

The poll’s full methodology could not be independently verified. Publication dates for the announcements also should not be mistaken for the dates when responses were collected.

Without that information, the percentages cannot support a claim that McEntee is the preferred candidate of college students generally or of young Republicans nationally.

Why the missing polling details matter

The American Association for Public Opinion Research’s disclosure standards call for information about a study’s sponsor, target population, question wording, recruitment, sample size and collection dates.

Those details help readers assess who a survey describes. An announcement from a campus organization does not, by itself, establish that participants represent everyone at the university or everyone sharing their political affiliation.

The association also distinguishes probability samples from volunteer or other non-probability samples. It says precision estimates for non-probability research require a defined model and an explanation of its assumptions and calculation.

No independently verified margin of error was available for either campus exercise. A national survey’s error estimate cannot be transferred to these results.

John McEntee’s political background

McEntee previously directed the White House Presidential Personnel Office during Donald Trump’s first administration. His own biography says he joined Trump’s campaign in 2015 and worked as the president’s personal aide before leading the personnel office.

After leaving government, he founded the conservative dating app The Right Stuff. His website also identifies him as a former senior adviser to the Heritage Foundation’s Project 2025 effort.

These roles explain his connection to Republican politics, but they do not establish the breadth of his support in a future primary. The biography is a source for his stated professional history, not independent evidence about the campus polls.

National preference surveys measure something different

In a November 13 analysis, YouGov reported that Vance and Rubio were the names most often supplied by people intending to participate in the 2028 Republican presidential primary. Respondents answered an open-ended question, and YouGov said it categorized their answers using an AI model.

That approach differs from a campus straw poll whose questionnaire and participant selection remain unverified. The findings cannot be combined into one ranking or treated as a direct measure of changing support over time.

Hourly Times previously examined early 2028 polling and the importance of respondent definitions. A candidate rating, a primary preference and a campus exercise answer different questions.

The next evidence needed to assess the John McEntee results is the organizers’ original questionnaires, participation totals and collection procedures. Until those are independently reviewed, the reported campus rankings remain a limited claim about two exercises.

Sources

Read smarter

Get The Hourly Brief in your inbox.

Essential U.S. politics, business, technology and health news—selected and explained by Hourly Times.

Join the newsletter